blog.MuchMusic.com www.MuchMusic.com

So, a debate was foisted on me just now regarding the Greatest Songwriter Of All Time. The caveat to this ‘discussion’ is that the songwriter has to be American. Not an easy feat when most of what you listen to is British, and, dare I say, most quality, prolific songwriters are also British (Robert Smith, Martin L. Gore, Damon Albarn, Morrissey, The Beatles)

Lots of names are being bandied about but I remain unconvinced: Paul Simon, Tom Waits, Bruce Springsteen, Bob Dylan, Ryan Adams.

So who is the greatest American songwriter, and why? What makes a great songwriter? Writing other people’s songs or putting your own voice to your music?

My answer, if we’re talking about contemporary songwriters that will be remembered five or even ten years from now, is Beck. He writes quality songs of surprising variety, ranging from heartwrenching (see also: anything on Sea Change) to funky (Mixed Bizness), to sexy (Debra) to lighthearted (I Think I’m In Love).

He’s remained culturally relevant for almost fifteen years now, and he’s constantly mixing up his sound and evolving as an artist while still maintaining critical and commercial acclaim. Thoughts?

Posted on Tuesday, August 21st, 2007 at 3:33 pm by Kat and is filed under Music & Videos.

Related Articles:

• NME Counts Down Greatest Indie Anthems
• Feist “How Come You Never Go There” (Beck Remix) (MP3)
• Songwriters vs. Singers
• Drake to receive Hall of Fame Songwriters Award
• New Video: Beck – Youthless