Liz Phair vs. Hilary Duff

December 5th, 2005

lizphairvshilaryduff.gifWhen Hilary Duff’s video for “Beat Of My Heart” surfaced a couple of weeks ago, I had a sudden rush of deja vu - for once it wasn’t the melody or the lyrics that were making me nostalgic - it was the VIDEO! Where had I seen this video concept before?

Look no further than Liz Phair’s 2003 video for “Why Can’t I?” for the answer. The videos are eerily similar, in fact, a side by side comparison, as done by Willa over here shows you just how identical these two videos are. Is Hilary a copycat? Most likely not - because both videos were in fact directed by THE SAME PERSON! Looks like Phil Harder’s run out of ideas. And if you take a listen to Liz Phair’s “Why Can’t I?” you will notice that she even sounds like today’s pop princesses.

Bookmark and Share

Related Articles:

2 Responses to “Liz Phair vs. Hilary Duff”

  1. EW, sorry but hilary duff, i hate her. ok i guess shes pretty but i find she follows alot and her sister *who just follows her and gets in her way and makes her music and videos even ,more crappy* follows too . but i like that fact her and joel are together because when they break up ill laugh!

    By Michelle L on December 5, 2005 at 7:29 pm |
  2. thats pretty sad how the video is exactly the same. But hey, if your directing liz phair and hilary duff i guess you wont have much of an imagination to begin with.

    By falteringstar on December 6, 2005 at 8:23 am |

Leave a Reply